Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Standing, A Metaphor in Familial and Social Structures As Observed in Readings of Kleist, Kafka, and Jarman



            In an overall analysis of the metaphor of standing we can reasonably conclude that its deployment in our vernacular is used heavily to signify a wide array of meaning that all can draw from to create a mutual understanding ranging from integrity, to steadfastness, to immovability etc. In the works by Kleist, Kafka, and Jarman we find clear and interesting examples of its deployment in settings of social and familial structures. While sharing the metaphor at heart each use of it is unique and profound.
            Kafka’s Metamorphosis explores the metaphor of standing through the role that Gregor has in his own family and his status outside of his family as well. It explores the idea of a man’s utility and worth based on his ability to provide and his ability to provide is derived from his status/stature. In his family Gregor alone is responsible for their financial wellbeing, their very livelihood, being faced with the challenge of taking on their debts. The father, ridden with age, is delicate and rather unexcitable old man that is heavily taxed by the prospect of standing he “who would receive (Gregor) sitting in the armchair in his nightgown when he came back in the evenings; who was hardly even able to stand up but, as a sign of his pleasure, would just raise his arms” The deliberate mentioning of the father’s inability to stand up but who would still stop and gather his family around him whenever he had something to say, paints a picture of a man who is past his time where he is able to provide but who continues to command the attention and respect of his family. This proves to be a struggle when the family is confronted with the sudden metamorphosis of their brother and son. In the beginning upon awakening Gregor discovers, to his dismay that his standing within his family and society could be at jeopardy, and his ability to control it is likewise compromised.
 “He lay on his hard, armorlike back, and when lifting his head slightly, he could view his brown, vaulted belly partitioned by arching ridges.”  He discovers in his supine position that even his own physical structure, his vaulted belly and arching ridges outstand him, and even while lifting his head, an attempt to oversee the new structure, does he see that his belly and ridges are still higher than that which should rightfully rest above. The theme of internal struggle to understand, be understood, and reclaim himself is recurring throughout. It is through this that is manifest, his struggle to deal with the prospect of being forevermore under the boots, as it were, of perceived superiors like his boss and father. Superiors that “talk down to the employees from their great height.” Indeed his entire dilemma could be seen as a delusion, onset by the “strenuous profession” that he picked and faced with the great task he is assigned, of freeing his parents from their debt, does he ironically find himself captive.  His metamorphosis is the embodiment of what keeps him down, making even the simplest of tasks overbearing.  Getting out of bed is his new “struggle.” “[It] was more of a game than a struggle… wrenching himself along, it occurred to him how easy everything would be if someone lent him a hand.” If only he could get a little understanding, and a little help would his lot be bearable. Therein lies the tragedy of the story, despite his desires to be reasonable and obliging he finds himself otherwise unable and stricken. And any attempt to make himself erect again comes with great unsustainable strain eventually leading to his ultimate demise of the ultimate lowliness of death.
            Kleist’s “The Marquis of O” shares some of the metaphorical employment of standing as Metamorphosis, as they share the quality of being centered on family life that is encased within societal expectations and perceptions.  The main difference lays in the circumstance of the story and the resolution.  The first point of great metaphor is that of using the metaphor to convey a moment of stunned disbelief when the Marquise receives the confirmation from the doctor that what she had suspected before, with regard to her condition, was indeed the case. “The Marquise stood as if thunderstruck.” This conveys an imagery of a nearly statue like posture. She finds herself in a moment that seems to be suspended in time. Like the apex of an object’s upward projectile, though lasting just a moment, that moment is an instance of absolute still suspension; in this case, where even her heart seems to stop.  Such intensity of being thunderstruck in that moment is merited by the societal expectations and the great shame that discovering a pregnancy outside of wedlock would bring upon and individual and the family to which they pertain.
 The Marquise and her mother go through phases of denial, calling the doctor a “shameless and contemptible wretch,” for even suggesting such a circumstance.  Yet she feels at that time, hostage to the verdict of the doctor and the testimony of her inner sensations that she knows only too well.  She expresses this by standing outside her present circumstance in hypothetical conjecture by saying, “If I knew that another woman was feeling as I do, would I not myself come to the conclusion that that was indeed how things stood with her?” This employment of the metaphor refers more to the wider use that the metaphor has in the narrative of circumstance. Given the societal climate in which they live, social standing is of utmost importance and such occurrences are seen as the pinnacle of shamefulness and are cause for great suffering for those that find themselves in a circumstance of that kind. 
Another instance of the standing metaphor used pertains to a physical posturing that directly conveys the emotion of the moment. When contemplating the necessity of a midwife to confirm the doctor’s conclusion the emotion of overwhelming shame brings the Marquise down to her knees. “‘A midwife!’ exclaimed the Commandant’s wife indignantly, ‘a clear conscience , and a midwife!’ And speech failed her. ‘A midwife, my dearest mother,’ repeated the Marquise, falling on her knees before her, ‘and let her come at once.’”  Another instance where the Marquise is faced with approaching the Commandant she, finding the door locked to his room, “sank down outside it, and in a heartrending voiced called upon the saints to witness her innocence.” Again overwrought with disgrace and frustration, her physical faculties will not allow her to maintain her stance. She is literally brought down, later splaying herself at the feet of the commandant in a gesture of utmost humility that is seen cross culturally as an acknowledging of someone who is superior. We make ourselves lower to physically demonstrate our figurative humility. 
            Iris uses the standing metaphor in a sense of an escape from harsh realities derived from bad decisions. A string of bad decisions had indeed left her in a state of disillusion and mostly unhappy save it were for making the best of mistake of marrying Cale by leaving him, even if it was after four years. Her life even so, goes far from ideal with the most operative word I can think of to describe it being, chaos. Notwithstanding, she says “You’d think with all the death in it, my life would be a tragedy. But I’ve kept my real life a secret—reading Jeffers. She longs for him because “He has been saved from human illusion and foolishness and passion and wants to be like a rock. That I miss something I think I have been steadfast, but what does a rock feel? I like him in bereavement.” Despite the disorder, the confusion, the fickle follies, and the dread we are inevitably all exposed to, she fixates on the part of her life that gives her a feeling of steadfastness, immovability and sanity. Jeffers represents that port in a storm of life. He is what she loves and holds onto, at times projecting him onto other people, thereby simultaneously projecting the love she feels for Jeffers. It is by way of this rock that she herself is able to withstand and endure.

1 comment:

  1. good second paragraph where you introduce the metamorphosis

    nice point about his vaulted belly outstanding him

    the thought about the delusion makes good sense

    the thunderstruck moment = statue = suspended in time -- good!

    as for Iris, what about the standing flower as compared to the standing tower.

    good essay overall.

    ReplyDelete